Shirley Gibbs Russell was an African American U.S. Marine Corps captain who was murdered in 1989 by her husband, Robert P. Russell. Her story inspired the 1997 movie Perfect Crime, starring Mitzi Kapture and Jasmine Guy. In the film, Mitzi Kapture plays a military investigator who has a hard time convicting an officer of killing his wife due to the absence of a body.
Few people knew the movie was based on Shirley Gibbs Russell, they changed her name in the movie, and there were no pics online. I brought you the story in 2004, 2008, and again in 2014. I remembered seeing the crime on an early documentary episode and realized it matched the movie.
 |
| Perfect Crime |
Robert and Shirley met in August 1985 while stationed at the Marine Corps base in Parris Island, South Carolina. Robert Russell was already married to Pamela Russell. They divorced a few months later, and Russell moved to another military base in Mississippi. He began seeing Shirley Russell, as well as other women. After two months, Shirley Gibbs married Robert Peter Russell. The marriage was stormy. Robert Russell was an abuser and a cheater. Shirley tried everything she could to save the marriage. She sought marriage counseling many times. She had no idea that he was planning her murder, The Morning Call reported.
She finally separated from Robert and moved to the bachelor's quarters. However, she planned to return to the married couple's quarters to continue moving her belongings. Shirley, 31, disappeared from her home on the military base in Quantico, Virginia, on March 4, 1989.
She had plans to meet her girlfriend, Patrice Gayle, for lunch. When Shirley did not show up at the expected time that afternoon, Patrice went to look for her. Russell, who was sweating profusely, told her that Shirley had walked to buy some paint. Gayle was shocked because Shirley never missed appointments. She wondered why Shirley would walk five miles in the bitter cold that Saturday afternoon to buy paint. After Shirley disappeared, Robert moved to Pennsylvania.
The government began investigating the disappearance of Shirley Russell. The investigation revealed the following: After Patrice Gayle left Russell's quarters, Russell visited another officer, where they talked and drank coffee. Russell was distracted the entire time and kept looking at the clock. He then stopped by the home of Sandy Flynt, one of his lovers, and took a shower. He called his parents and made arrangements to visit them.
He asked to borrow Flynt's car, even though he had a truck of his own. Neighbors testified that they saw the car backed into a storage shed next to the Russells' home.
A computer disk had also been discovered in Mississippi under the file name "murder." It contained what was described as a guide to murdering someone in twenty-six steps. Investigators also recovered a pistol and evidence of numerous extramarital affairs.
 |
| Shirley Gibbs Russell and Robert Russell the Recipe for Murder Killer |
Friends and family testified that Russell made it clear that he would know exactly what to do to get rid of a body by throwing it down a mine shaft. The government contended that Robert Russell was jealous because Shirley Russell was a role model and a symbol of the Marine Corps. Meanwhile, Robert had numerous problems, including drinking, unexplained absences, and questionable spending practices, which ultimately led to his discharge.
Where Was Shirley Killed?
Prosecutors believed Robert shot Shirley in a storage shed next to their former living quarters at Quantico. They believed he shot his wife with a .25-caliber pistol and then dumped her body into a mine shaft or sinkhole somewhere in Pennsylvania. Her body has never been found.
Robert was convicted and sentenced to life in prison in 1991.
The story was bizarre because Robert kept detailed murder notes referred to as a "recipe for murder." He wrote, "How do I kill her?"
Robert Russell said he planned to write a book to tell the public what really happened. He said that Shirley was still alive and that the government was conspiring against him. An officer or two swore that they had seen her. When Robert's mother found out he was being investigated for the murder of his wife, she threw away Robert's writings.
A Conversation with Shirley's Sister
According to my 2008 notes, I spoke with Shirley Gibbs Russell's sister on Thursday, May 29, 2008. She said the family was doing well, but she did not focus much on the case because she felt it had all passed. She told me she had only seen the movie once.
Because no body was ever found, it appears that Robert Russell pulled off what could be described as the perfect crime.
Cited Sources
The Charley Project
Book: Deliberate Intent by Rodney A. Smolla